Advantages/Disadvantages Direct Democracy

Disadvantage

Many topics are too complex for the people to understand. Eg 2011 AV referendum

Disadvantage

A very close result in a referendum may result in unsatisfactory conclusion and fail to achieve acceptance of the outcome. Scotland independence referendum 2014, 55.30% N

Disadvantage

Can be subverted or distorted by wealthy groups who influence the debate

Advantage

Disperses power widely among the population rather than having power concentrated within a few hands

Advantage

Form of educating the public

Disadvantage

If required to participate too much the population may become politically fatigued and apathy will grow. In 1998, the referendum in Ldn only had a 34% voter turnout.

Disadvantage

Often creates an emotional rather than a rational response from the people and the media. For example a vote on capital punishment

Advantage

People are more likely to accept the decision if they have been consulted

Advantage

People become more involved with politics which therefore enhances democracy

Advantage

Purest form of democracy dating back to Ancient Athens