CMST 1111 Final Exam Study Set
What are myths in essence?
"Bad science."
Love objects
"Children and adults want both to love and be loved. Children have dolls and teddy bears, but what do adults have? They have one another, their cars, their pets and gadgets. They need something to love and if they do not have something they will buy or make one." Example: Adverts offer to take us back to childhood with childlike personalities. They sell us things to love and things for our loved ones (including our pets).
Ego gratification
"Ego gratification is related to worth in that they are both about the sense of identity, but this is perhaps a little more base, were we a need for praise and our egos to be 'stroked'." Example: When we do something at work we want to be congratulated and praised, much as we needed to be valued and praised as a child. "You should buy L'Oreal because you know why? You're worth it. Your ego is worth L'Oreal."
J.R.R. Tolkien (1892-1973)
"Father" of modern fairytale literacy,
Michel Foucault Quote
"If we live in an era of one upping-ship, how to we create control? You don't. You create the illusion"
Reassurance of worth
"In a connected world we can lose sense of who we are and what we are worth. We thus seek reassurance that we are adding value and deserve our place in society" Emotions: doing the right thing, eg saving the environment or helping others. Celebrities are also used when they effectively say 'you will be admired and valued like me. Example: If you wear this watch, you will be admired like me
Roots
"Our roots are a key part of our sense of identity. Where we come from, our heritage, our family, our nation are important for that feeling of who we are. The longer we stay in one place and the longer ago it happened, the more important it is for us. And yet we live mobile lives, flitting from place to place, job to job. We seek roots but in seeking to satisfy other needs we make ourselves rootless." Emotions: We have a place to call home Example: We identify with our old school, our college, where we were brought up, our country, our employer, our religion.
Immortality
"Perhaps the biggest fear we have is of death. Or maybe not death but of ceasing, of becoming nothing. We likewise seek to create meaning in our lives so we may live beyond death. We love to believe that we will always be young, always be beautiful, and always live forever" Emotions: It takes away our fear of death. Example: We have children, write books, build companies and more. We also seek to cheat age, striving to look younger when perhaps we should grow older more gracefully.
Thorstein Veblen (1857-1929)
"Technology as Communication linked as social progress."
Rosalind Williams
"Technology determines history."
Charles A. Beard (1874-1948)
"Technology marches in seven league boots from one ruthless revolutionary conquest to another, tearing down old factories and industries, flinging up new processes with terrifying rapidity"
Michael L. Smith
"The belief that social progress is driven by technological innovation, which in turn follows as 'inevitable' course."
Lance Packer
"The consumer is not a fool, the consumer is your wife."
Bruce Bimber
"The idea that technological development determines social change..."
Big Bakhtin idea
"The sacred with the profane, the new and the old, the high and the low"
Creative outlets
"We all like creating and making things, and even a simple assembly process as with Lego toys can bring much pleasure. Many jobs have little creative content, leaving this need unfulfilled. We thus seek creative opportunity in other parts of our life." Example: Adverts offer creativity when they sell objects where we can be creative, from food ingredients to clothes.
Emotional Security
"We all start out as fragile emotional beings and very few of us achieve deep emotional security, so we all keep seeking it." Emotions: comfort, happiness, and banishing of bad feelings, security aspect, emphasizing home, permanence and safety Example: Temple University ads
What was the goal of torturing Damien?
"We can break their body, but the goal is to break their will."
What was the goal of the Panopticon?
"We don't break the mind, we create the docile body."
Sense of power
"When we are in control we a sense of ability to choose and perhaps power over others. When we can direct others we move up the social order and so are, theoretically at least, safer." Emotion: Buying something will put you in charge Example: Big cars, chunky tools, solid houses and old banks all make us feel safe and, when we own or use them, powerful.
Aspects of Bakhtin
- Free and familiar interaction between differing people - Eccentric behavior - Carnivalistic misalliances - Sacrilegious
C.S. Lewis myth characteristics
1. A myth is pre-eminently a pattern of events and is, as such, communicable by any medium capable of reproducing the pattern: mime, film, dance, even (perhaps) Hermann Hesse's "Glasperlenspiel. 2. The pleasure of myth is independent of the usual narrative devices of surprise or suspense 3. As a consequence, characterization is relatively unimportant and the individual persons or personal agents that appear in myths are typically underdeveloped by comparison with, say, the practice of a novelist 4. Myth is usually fantastic, dealing with preternatural events, persons, and relationships. Myth is always grave and we feel it to be ominous, even awe-inspiring.
Technology is 2 things:
1. A predictable path largely beyond cultural or political influence 2. Society organizes itself to support and develop a technology or technology overall once being introduced
When was Foucault born?
1926
The Mechanical Bride
1951 - Addresses the change in American society from agrarian to urban population centers with the development of factories and communication effects accompanying such changes.
McLuhan's biggest goal
A return to the global village, and media will return us there
Myth
A sophisticated and abstract mode of thought. Advances primary culture values and reinforces fundamental power structures
Packer's Idea of Ads
Ads force us to broadcast our identity to the world, we use them to say much about our personal identity
Myths can be used to...
Advance fundamental religious or metaphysical visions of the world at large. Sometimes they fail.
When and where did Foucault die?
Age 57 in 1984, Cimetiere du Vendeuvre in Vienne, passed away from AIDS
Who did Tolkien honor?
Andrew Lang
Sociological myth
Being mythologies help maintain social norm
Postmodernists
Believe things are always situational or temporary and there is no universal truth or stability
Discipline and Punish (1974)
Book by Foucault, "It is the act of punishment, not the punishment itself" Punishing and disciplining people are both constantly changing
Two Myths of the Harlem Shake
Carnival and strict hierarchical order/terror dogmatism
Examples of Eucatastrophe
Christian Gospel and The Birth of Christ The Resurrection in the Incarnation
Modernism
Creates a mirage to mask the creation of this "disorder"
Cosmological myth
Dealing with the origins of the universe
What book did Foucault study?
Descartes' First Meditation
McLuhan's Background
English lit, wrote Mechanical Brides
"Sight" Directors
Eran May-raz, Daniel Lazo
Foucault's role of advocacy
Every attempt to create 'order' always demands the creation of an equal amount of disorder
Where is myth studied?
Fields of anthropology, archeology, and the study of religion
Life Purpose
Finding the balance between Apollo and Dionysus aspects
What was Foucault's thesis paper?
Folie et deraison: Histoire de la folie a l'âge classique. It becomes known as Madness and Unreason: History of Madness in the Classical Age (1961).
Marshall McLuhan (1911-1977)
Force in the field, godfather, 6"8, Professor of University of Toronto, Canadian There is still a statue of him in the University of Toronto Age of Television
US TV Channels
Four channels all located in the US that had lack of representation and debatable representation
How many myths exist?
Four; Mystical, Cosmological, Sociological, and Psychological
Who's ideas did Foucault parallel?
Friedrich Nietzsche who "marked the beginning of the end of Modernism"
Dionysus
Grapes + Wine Grapevine in hair Perpetual party guy Expression, debauchery, disorder
What is 125th street?
Harlem
When was the Harlem Shake really invented?
Harlem in 80's
Who inspired Foucault?
Heidegger and Nietzsche
Plato's Cave
Informs us on the realm of eternal objects from which the soul has come and to which it returns after many reincarnations. Also tells us about the spiritual and moral values of the soul when it tries to return to its origins.
What is the role of dance in the communication of cultural identity?
It is a form of nonverbal communication that often tells a story of one's culture.
What does the Harlem Shake represent?
It is a statement about class
Panopticon
Jeremy Benthem's idea of a circular prison with cells arranged around a central well, from which prisoners could at all times be observed.
Damiens the Regicide
Killed the king and was publicly tortured to prove a point to the public. PUBLIC ASPECT IS KEY.
Willing Suspension of Disbelief
Literary belief; the reader's mind enters a Secondary World. Inside it, what relates is and therefore alters what is considered to be "true." However, that truth has to be credible which commands the writer to be creative and have an elvish craft.
What is Carnival?
Madness and chaos that brings people together "That which is sacred becomes overcome by profane"
Paradox of McLuhan
McLuhan's media theory seeks to use electronic media to return original place of self-presence, identity, community - the global village.
What type of theorist was McLuhan?
Media theorist
Are Apollo and Dionysus killing each other?
No, they are wrestling
Half of Canada believes
Only 17% of Canada has a Neo-Nazi problem More than half of the US has a Neo-Nazi problem
Psychological myth
Or the creation of a shared psyche
Where was Foucault born?
Poitiers, France
Was Foucault modernist or post-modernist?
Postmodernist
What to prisoners do in the panopticon?
Prisoners internalize the guard's gaze They become paranoid
Postmodernism
Rejects the idea that there is a grand scheme to things
Apollo and Dionysus
Represent the basis of oodles of philosophy
What did Foucault study?
Sex, death, punishment, and drugs
Global Village
Simplifying of the whole world into one village through the use of electronic media // Created by Marshall McLuhan
What McLuhan learns
Stereotypes against Canadians becomes english literature He understands the power of words to create meaning He finds American stories, and there are interpersonal stories but intermediate
Fairy-stories
Stories not concerned with possibility, but with desirability. With desire, comes success in stories
Apollo
Systematic learning Truth and music Insight, light Order, focus
Augmented Reality
Takes a real time photo and puts sometime on top of it, different than VR
Mystical myth
That which enables human beings to accept the burdens of life
What myth does the Bible mimic?
The Combat Myth
C.S. Lewis
The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe, said myths need six basic characteristics to be successful
Docile Body (Foucault)
The idea that constant supervision and forced discipline broke the will of the criminal and made him easy to control by people in authority
Why does Foucault believe the prison system lasted so long?
The ruling class used criminality as a way of preventing confrontations that could lead to revolution. It gave them power.
What was Tolkien influenced by?
The way stories were presented to him, and the inherent tone and quality of those stories.
Technological Determinism
Theory that assumes that a society's technology determines the development of its social structure and cultural values
Benefits of criminalizing outcasts
They are easier to supervise and keep disorganized by keeping the members flowing in and out of the prison system, and they cannot affect the political system
What do myths do?
They seek to mediate to us ultimate realities, those which lie beyond the reach of our ordinary experience
What is the overall response to the "new" Harlem Shake in Harlem?
They think it is disrespectful and appropriating their culture. "That's west fourth dancing"
Why do we buy things?
Things buy you immortality because they continue when you die
Charles Bead view on tech
Thought it had a negative impact such as the decline in farming
Regicide
To kill the regit, killing of a king
Eucatastrophe
Tragedy is to drama as _________ is to fairy-tales
What McLuhan does
Turns on television to find out what it means to be Canadian
Where did Foucault teach?
University of Warsaw and the University of Hamburg (French) University of Cermont- Ferrand (Philosophy) University of Paris- VIII at Viennes (directed dept. of Philosophy in 1968) College de France (Professor of History of Systems of Thought, 1970)
There is a reference to West 4th What does that mean and does it link to the above?
West Fourth is a boujee capital that has very wealthy stores and is predominantly white.
Industrial Revolution (1760)
What Beard wrote about negatively because industry was taking over and rural places turn into cities while farmers have to become factory workers.
Are children capable of literary belief?
Yes, if the story-maker is good enough to produce it.
palimpsest
a very old document on which the original writing has been erased and replaced with new writing
Hot medium
allows for less participation
Cold medium
appeals to people on tv
Heilbroner Argument (from long reading)
technology is developed step by step and to get where we are now // ex: A society cannot have nuclear technology without passing through electricity
