FIN 3320 Chapter 10 Moore
Hodor Manufacturing Co.'s (HMC) common stock currently sells for $50.00 per share. Assume the stock is in a state of constant growth, has an expected dividend yield of 4.5%, and an expected capital gains yield of 6.5%. The current dividend payout ratio is 30% and the firm's return on equity is 9.3%. The firm requires external funds for a new project and anticipates issuing additional shares of common stock at its current price of $50.00. However, the process of issuing this new equity is expected to result in a flotation expense equivalent to 10% of the stock price. If the firm goes ahead with its equity issue, what will be the firm's cost for this new common stock, re?
11.50% Dividend yield = D1/P0 4.5% = D1/$50.00 D1 = $2.25 re = D1/[P0(1 - F)] + g = $2.25/[$50.00(1 - 0.10)] + 0.065 = 11.50%
Roland Corporation's next expected dividend (D1) is $2.50. The firm has maintained a constant payout ratio of 50% during the past 7 years. Seven years ago its EPS was $1.50. The firm's beta coefficient is 1.2. The estimated market risk premium is 6%, and the risk-free rate is 7%. Roland's A-rated bonds are yielding 10%, and its current stock price is $30. Which of the following values is the most reasonable estimate of Roland's cost of retained earnings, rs?
14% Use all three methods to estimate rs. CAPM: rs = rRF + (RPM)b = 7% + (6%)1.2 = 14.2% Risk Premium: rs = Bond yield + Risk premium = 10% + 4% = 14% DCF: rs = D1/P0 + g = $2.50/$30 + g, where g can be estimated as follows using a financial calculator: Enter N = 7, PV = -0.75, PMT = 0, and FV = 2.50, and solve for I/YR = g = 18.77% = 18.8%. Therefore, rs = 0.083 + 0.188 = 27.1% Roland Corporation has apparently been experiencing supernormal growth during the past 7 years, and it is not reasonable to assume that this growth will continue. The first two methods yield rs of about 14%, which appears reasonable.
Which of the following should NOT be included when calculating the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) for use in capital budgeting?
Accounts Payable Long-term debt, retained earnings, common stock, and preferred stock are components of WACC
Assume that All-American Sporting Goods correctly estimates its WACC at a given point in time and then uses that same cost of capital to evaluate all projects for the next 10 years. The firm will most likely:
Become more risky and also have an increasing WACC. Its intrinsic value will not be maximized. Low-risk projects will tend to have low expected returns and vice versa for high-risk projects due to competition in the economy. By not adjusting the cost of capital for project risk, the firm will tend to reject low-risk projects even though they earn higher returns than their risk-adjusted costs of capital, and vice versa for high-risk projects. As the firm takes on more high-risk projects, its true WACC will increase over time. Of course, the true WACC might change over time due to changes in market conditions, but that could cause the true WACC to either rise or decline. Therefore, statement d is correct.
If the debt ratio is 50%, the interest rate on new debt is 8%, the tax rate is 40%, and the current cost of equity is 16%, then an increase in the debt ratio to 60% would have to decrease the weighted average cost of capital (WACC).
False An increase in the debt ratio may increase the interest rate on debt and the current cost of equity. See Section 10.8, Factors that Affect the WACC
Because the before-tax cost of debt is lower than the after-tax cost, it is used as the component cost of debt for purposes of developing the firm's WACC.
False The after-tax cost of debt is lower than the before-tax cost.
As a general rule, firms should use their weighted average cost of capital (WACC) to evaluate capital budgeting projects. After all, most projects are funded with general corporate funds, which come from a variety of sources. However, if the firm plans to use only debt or only equity to fund a particular project, it should use the after-tax cost of that specific type of capital to evaluate that project.
False In general, this statement is false, because the firm should be viewed as an ongoing entity, and using debt (or equity) to fund a given project will change the capital structure, and this factor should be recognized by basing the cost of capital for all projects on a target capital structure. Under some special circumstances, where a project is set up as a separate entity, "project financing" may be used, and only the project's specific situation is considered. This is a specific situation, however, and not the "in general" case.
Modern Fashions, Inc. and New York Accessories Co. are identical in size and capital structure. However, Modern Fashions has a WACC of 10% and New York Accessories a WACC of 12%, because the riskiness of their assets and cash flows somewhat different. New York Accessories is considering Project Y, which has an IRR of 11.5% and is of the same risk as a typical New York Accessories project. Modern Fashions is considering Project X, which has an IRR of 10.5% and is of the same risk as a typical Modern Fashions project. Now assume that the two companies merge and form a new company, New York Modern, Inc. Moreover, the new company's market risk is an average of the pre-merger companies' market risks, and the merger has no impact on either the cash flows or the risks of Projects X and Y. Which of the following statements is CORRECT?
If the firm evaluates these projects and all other projects at the new overall corporate WACC, it will probably become riskier over time.
Red Bird Manufacturing would like to avoid issuing new stock because new stock has a higher cost than retained earnings, but the company forecasts that if all of its existing financial policies are followed, its proposed capital budget would be so large that it would have to issue new common stock. Which of the following actions would REDUCE its need to issue new common stock?
Increase the percentage of debt in the target capital structure. Increase the percentage of debt in the target capital structure is correct, because if more debt is used, then less equity will be needed to fund the capital budget, so the need for a stock issue would be reduced.
The chief financial officer of Panther Products, which is an all-equity firm with a beta of 2.0, is evaluating a project with an expected return of 14%, before any risk adjustment. The risk-free rate is 5%, and the market risk premium is 4%. The project being evaluated is riskier than the firm's average project in terms of both its beta risk and its total risk. Which of the following statements is CORRECT?
The accept/reject decision depends on the firm's risk-adjustment policy. If Panther's policy is to increase the required return on a riskier-than-average project to 3% over rS, then it should reject the project. The accept/reject decision depends on the firm's risk-adjustment policy. If Panther's policy is to increase the required return on a riskier-than-average project to 3% over rS, then it should reject the project is correct. Here is the proof: rs = 5% + 4%(2.0) = 5% + 8% = 13%. Required return for risky projects = 13% + 3% = 16%. Project return = 14% < adjusted rs = 16%. Thus, the project should be rejected.
Akita Development, which has an overall WACC of 12%, has equal amounts of low-risk, average-risk, and high-risk projects. The CFO believes that this is the correct WACC for the company's average-risk projects, but that a lower rate should be used for lower-risk projects and a higher rate for higher-risk projects. The CEO disagrees on the grounds that even though projects have different risks, the WACC used to evaluate each project should be the same because the company obtains capital for all projects from the same sources. What is likely to happen over time if the CEO's position is accepted?
The company will take on too many high-risk projects and reject too many low-risk projects. Low-risk projects will tend to have low expected returns and vice versa for high-risk projects due to competition in the economy. By not adjusting the cost of capital for project risk, the firm will tend to reject low-risk projects even though they earn higher returns than their risk-adjusted costs of capital, and vice versa for high-risk projects. In addition, as the firm takes on more high-risk projects, its correct WACC will increase over time. Therefore, statement a is correct.
Which of the following statements could be true concerning the costs of debt and equity?
The cost of debt for Firm A is greater than the cost of equity for Firm B. The cost of retained earnings for Firm A is less than its cost of new outside equity. If Firm A has more business risk than Firm B, Firm A's cost of debt could be greater than Firm B's cost of equity. Also, the cost of retained earnings is less than the cost of new outside equity due to flotation costs.
Global Goodness Foods has two divisions of equal size: a snack food division and a beverage division. The company's CFO believes that stand-alone snack food companies typically have a WACC of 8%, while stand-alone beverage producers typically have a 12% WACC. He also believes that the snack food and beverage divisions have the same risk as their typical peers; consequently, the CFO estimates that the composite, or corporate, WACC is 10%. A consultant has suggested using an 8% hurdle rate for the snack food division and a 12% hurdle rate for the beverage division. However, the CFO disagrees, and he has assigned a 10% WACC to all projects in both divisions. Which of the following statements is CORRECT?
The decision not to adjust for risk means that the company will accept too many projects in the beverage division and too few in the snack food division. This will lead to a reduction in the firm's intrinsic value over time.
An increase in a firm's marginal tax rate would lower the cost of debt used to calculate its WACC, other things held constant.
True
Because they are based on investors' required returns, the component costs of capital are market-determined variables.
True
Funds acquired by the firm through preferred stock have a cost to the firm equal to the preferred dividend divided by the current price of the preferred stock. If significant flotation costs are involved the cost of the preferred should be adjusted upward.
True
In capital budgeting, the cost of capital should reflect the average cost of the various sources of investor-supplied funds a firm uses to acquire assets.
True
One definition of "capital" is funds supplied to a firm by investors.
True
Retained earnings have a cost equal to rs because investors expect to earn rs on investments with the same risk as the firm's common stock. If the firm cannot earn rs on the earnings that it retains, it should pay those earnings out to its investors. Thus, the cost of retained earnings is based on the opportunity cost principle.
True
To find the cost of perpetual preferred stock, divide the preferred's annual dividend by the market price of the preferred stock. No adjustment is needed for taxes because preferred dividends, unlike interest on debt, are not deductible by the issuing firm.
True
Which of the following sequences is CORRECT for a typical firm? All rates are after taxes, and assume that the firm operates at its target capital structure.
re > rs > WACC > rd. The cost of new common stock is greater than the cost of retained earnings, which is greater than the cost of debt, meaning that WACC is greater than the cost of debt
