Fintech 2
A priori segmentation
Is planned, researcher choose some segment-defining characteristics in advance e.g. age
Benefits of credit cards for customers
-Acceptance levels -Reward points -Airport lounge access -Joining fee/welcome bonus -Buyer protection -Status symbol
Who are the players in the market
-Banks -Private banks -Family offices -Asset management firms -Financial advisors
To accept credit cards
-Banks pay for their global network coverage with ATM's & merchant terminals (POS) -They're not a bank -Not liable for any dispute -Middle men processing the payment for banks & merchants
Benefits of the robo-advisor (more 5)
-Better accuracy -Transparency -Bias & conflicts reduced -Big data -Collaborate & engage with customers
Difference between credit & debit card
-Both eliminate need to carry cash -Fundamental difference is where card pulls money Debit: Pulls from your banking account Credit: Charges to your line of credit
Impact of robe-advisory on wealth management
-HNW also becoming interested -Boomers inheriting money have different attitudes (want more transparency & control) -Transparency, control, usability
Major types of robo-advisors
1. Standalone or independently operated robo-advisors 2. Robo-advisor accounts developed or brought on by incumbents
Three main and highly interrelated disruptive factors, which have helped the market develop in this area
1. Technology enables innovation 2. Regulatory intervention 3. Shift in consumer preferences
Post hoc descriptive & predictive methods
Descriptive: Factor analysis and cluster analysis Predictive: Combine post hoc grouping with predictive predisposition, e.g. automatic interaction detector (AID) & canonical analysis
Segmentation basis
Is the characteristic or groups of characteristics of consumers used to assign consumers to segments -Varies among groups of a certain market -Consistent within each group
Market infrastructures for settlements
Is the completion of a transaction System used to facilitate the settlement of transfers of funds
Strategic asset allocation process
It is an approach towards portfolio construction It helps determine the allocation to asset classes considered for the investment
4 types of loans
-General loans -World poverty reduction -Family and friends loans -Specialized loans (e.g. for student loans)
List of criteria or basic strategies to segment the consumer market
-Geographic -Demographic -Psychographic -Buyer behavior
New fintech business models for advisory
-Comparison websites (provide investment advice) -Financial aggregator platforms (allow user to link accounts across multiple financial institutions) -Social trading & investment platforms -Robo-advisors
3 main features for their digital business
-Content: what is consumed? -Experience: how is it packaged? -Platform: How is it delivered
Pain points in traditional monetary subsitutes
-Costs -User experience -Time waiting -No control on spending -Fraud
Pain points of neo banks
-Customer acquisition -Customer retention -Scalability -Profit model
Can classify variables according to the fact that they are
-Customer specific -Situation specific * Can further break this down into observable and unobservable bases
Forms of payment cards
-Debit -Credit -Pre-paid
Risks more specific to p2p lending platforms
-Default risk of borrower -Liquidity risk/lack of secondary market liquidity for the loans
Statistical methods to be used (there are 2)
-Description methods: structural, interdependence methods since they analyze mutual association across variables (no distinction between independent & dependent variables) -Predictive methods: analyze the relationships between 2 sets of variables (distinction between independent & dependent variables)
Concerns related to innovations
-Devalue role of professional advisor -Disintermediation -Belief financial planning cannot be carried out adequately by inhuman appliances -Some believe will make market less profitable
Different forms of crowdfunding can be classified as
-Donation/philanthropic (very low risk) -Reward/commerical-based: finances ideas can be rewarded non monetarily -Royalty: share profits from monetary investment -Crowd investing
Benefits of the robo-advisor (first 5)
-Effective -Younger & less wealthy clients -Free professionals to devote time to other things -Data collection -Updates real time-market changes
Benefits of market segmentation
-Enables cost reduction -Enhanced customer satisfaction -Certain groups can be selected to exclusion of others -New customer requirements can be anticipated -Customer retention improved -Enhanced brand reputation -Differentiation purposes -Increased customer value -Being more market oriented
Types of crowd investing
-Equity-based crowdfunding -Lending-based crowdfunding -Invoice trading
MiFID II can be separated into three core pillars (market in financial instruments directive)
-Fairer, safer and more efficient markets -Stronger investment protection -Greater transparency
Corporate market poses distinct characteristics which market it different from personal market
-Fewer in number compared to individuals -More complex financial requirement
PFM key activities
-Financial needs analysis -Risk appetite -Holding period -Life styles analysis and sources of wealth -Portfolio composition: proposal -Portfolio management and implementation -Monitorin -Rebalancing
Requirements for effective market segmentation
-Homogeneous (with their segments) & heterogeneous (with other segments) -Measurable (measure effectiveness of segment) -Substantial enough to be profitable -Accessibile (segment has to be reachable) -Actionable & different in its response to a marketing mix -Stable -Appropriate for the company's policies and resources
Banks use as key vectors for segmenting the SME banking market the following
-Industry sector -Customer profile
PFM value proposition
-Investment advice ---Tailor services -Financial planning -Tax planning -Fiscal advisor -Corporate finance (on demand) -Succession plans -Art advisory -Legal advisory -Real estate advisor -Retirement planning
Fintechs new story about payments
-It is not in the payment itself or in the payment mechanism -But in what the payment does for the customer, merchant, and other service providers Value in connecting each individual with their money in different ways
Mobile payments can be classified as the following
-Mobile remote payment (pay independently of phone's location) -Mobile proximity payment (for in-store) -Mobile P2P payments
Ways new wave of digitalization has changed the financial advice landscape
-Move focus from PFM to personal financial performance -Increasing use of tablets/mobile devices for direct advisory -Increasing visual approach -Develop real-time messaging -Advice becoming increasingly real time
More fintechs address their value proposition to small medium enterpises (SME's)
-Offer them basic bank service -Create platforms for matching lenders & borrowers -Multi-sided platform market
Non-cash payment methods
-Payment cards: Can take cash out of ATM and used to pay vendors at point of sale -Bank transfers: Payment orders made by debtors to transfer sum to creditor -Direct debits: Where one individual withdraws funds from another person's bank account -Checks: Negotiable instrument instruction financial institution to pay an amount from an account in makers name
Fintechs can be grouped according to what parties are invovled
-Peer to peer (P2P) -Business to person (B2P) -Person to business (P2B) -Business to business (B2B)
Success of payment instruments usually constrained by
-Presence of reliable clearing and settlement infrastructures -Sufficiently wide acceptance -Adoption of common standards -Definition of security requirements and guidelines
Cost structure of players in the markets
-Provision of financial instruments (in-house production vs. open architecture) -Costs for info, data providers, other related services -Labour costs for portfolio managers, advisors, specialists, etc. -Distribution (branches/offices, etc.) Etc.
Growth in P2P propelled by
-Reduced technology costs -Previously underserved market segments -Low interest rates -Risk diversification
Risks in lending platforms
-Risk of conducting general solicitation/unlicensed activities -Disclosure risks: may lack standardisation -Cross-border risk: multiple jurisdictions -Rick of collapse/malpractice: leads to less trust and repetitional risk -Risk of fraud
Risks more specific to the robo-advisor
-Risks of errors in algorithms -Risks of overly complex algorithms -Risks of overly simplistic algorithms -Risk of static client information
Hybrid approach of technology & human touch
-Role of advisors as decision validators -Continuous and regular conversation with advisors -Combines goals-based planning with technology -Removes many middle-office administrative tasks, allowing advisors to focus on areas of highest value to their clients -Client provided with broader services
Two approaches to segmentation
-Segments are developed in advance (a-priori) -Segments are developed widely using data based on customer behavior (post hoc)
Streamlined payments
-Services such as location-based payments e.g. geotagging, -Machine to machine payments -Mobile point of sale e.g. paypal
How neobanks are radically changing customer expectations
-Smartphones helps retain customers by deepening relationships -Focus on better & friendlier experience -Emphasis on transparency, bring down commissions and fees
Value proposition of Neo banks
-Solve pain points with other banks -Give banking to those who are unbanked
Investment choices
-Stocks and bonds -Futures and options -Mutual funds -Exchange-traded fund -Prebuilt portfolios
When credit cards e.g. American Express are issued by American express
-They issue cards & process payments on their own network -Some of them may be better at dispute handling (better at saving you from issues) -Charge higher transaction fees
Factors explaining growth of robo-advisory in market
-Universal tightening of regulations -Blooming period of US stocks -Extensive expansion of smartphone usage -Realization that robo-advisors have appeal to affluent and HNW (high net worth) investors as well as retail customers.
How do banks segment individuals in practice
-Wealth of the customer -Volume of business done with the banks -Usage of financial services
Key reasons why industry sector is such a ubiquitous segmentation dimension are the following
-key factor in the risk characteristics of customers -strongly linked to geographic competitive advantage -rich with statistical data on size, structure, growth, and trade relationships
Neo-bank based on two main criteria
1. Bank license vs non-bank license 2. Relationship-only vs full service
Four market segments in cross-border payments ((how do they work))
1. Capturing: interfacing directly with users 2. Messaging: involved handling payment instructions 3. Settlement: Involves 1. Transfer of money from bank to bank domestically), 2. Transfer of funds across borders (cross-border settlement) 4. Disbursing: involves interfacing with clients again
Two interesting areas in payments
1. Cross-border payments 2. Mobile payments
How robo advisors work
1. Gather info from clients on their financial situation & goals with questionanaire 2. Robo-advisors use algorithms to determine risks & allocate assets 3. Clients personalized portfolio structured to achieve optimal returns at every level of risk
Traditional p2p lending model (6 steps)
1. Investors & borrowers subscribe to platform 2. Investor/borrower verified & b assigned credit score 3. Loan request displayed on platform 4. Investor decides where to invest 5. Once borrowers request funded, conditions are shown 6. Platform rules the money transactions between borrowers and lenders and intervenes in case of delayed payments
Top 10 fintech issues (1-5)
1. Lack of understanding by consumers 2. Ability of automated questionnaries & risk anaylsis 3. Potential conflict of interest with automated service providers 4. Cybersecurity 5. Regulators understanding the complexity
Can classify the platforms according to two alternatives
1. Reverse auction: l set min interest rate & b set their max 2. Automatic matching: platform sets rates
Small medium enterprises (SMEs) is the typical business segment for a retail bank Serving them requires answers these key questions
1.How can banks better understand SME customer needs? 2. How can they match diverse needs with the right offer, service level, and delivery channel? 3. How can customer management be used to maximize the revenue opportunity when servicing this market segment? 4. How can banks effectively manage SME customers across their life‐cycle?
Top 10 fintech issues (6-10)
6. Inadequate disclosure to those accessing 7. How execution only platforms vet clients 8. Inadequate competence/supervision of humans that support device 9. Inadequate testing of advice of algorithm 10. Inadequate training or competencies of those developing algorithms
Thanks to fintech lending has become
Cheap & ubiquitous -Credit in various forms -Given in communities that typically don't have this access
Integrated billing mobile
Consists of payment services such as ordering and payment apps and integrated mobile shopping apps e.g. Uber
A priori descriptive & predictive methods
Descriptive: Cross-classifying the variables in contingency tables Predictive: Regression or discriminant analysis
Market segmentation bases: the business market
Distinction between large corporate customers and small businesses -Differ in nature and scale of financial requirements & expertise
Post hoc segmentation
Driven by empirical concerns after seeing the data e.g. purchasing behavior or attitudes
First takeaway
Each new payment must be better in some features to substitute an old one
Fintech firms fall into one of two categories
Fintech fin: Work directly with consumers Fintech techs: concentrate on providing specialized technologies for banks
Fintechs & payments
Fintechs started mostly with payments, now may seem to be shifting away to become a data industry
Credit cards are e.g. visa
Global networks that process payments and charge a fee for that
Neo-bank
Innovative approaches to day-to-day banking -Internet only -Focused on multichannel landscape -Range of products offered
Time horizon
Length of time over which an investment is made or held before it is liquidated
Second takeaway
Level of acceptance for any monetary substitute is FUNDAMENTAL and depends on network of merchants
Emphasis on what factors in cross-border payments
Low cost Security Convenience Predictability Transparency Assumption of confidentiality
World bank's says a possible classification is the number of employees and turnover
Micro: 1-9 employees Small: 10-49 Medium: 50-99
Guidelines bank follows to segment their individual customer base #1
Minimizing the amount of strategic segments towards 3 or 4 Allows for proper managerial focus
Financial advisory
More than a service it is a method of matching investment needs with the investments factors (has many dimensions according to needs)
about SMEs
SMEs more than any-other banking segment vary by size, sector, financial sophistication, business maturity -Not a one size fits all approach -Don't treat as homogeneous group
Customer specific (observable & unobservable)
Observable: Cultural, geographic, demographic etc. Unobservable: Psychographics (personality & lifestyle)
Situation specific (observable & unobservable)
Observable: User status, usage, frequency, brand-loyalty etc. Unobservable: Psychographics (benefits, perceptions, attitudes)
Guidelines bank follows to segment their individual customer base #2
Other segmentation parameters: -Assets & liabilities -Life stage -Equipment rate (product amount, account activity) -Financial potential
Market infrastructures for clearing
Process of transmitting, reconciling orders prior to settlement
Mobile money
Refers to a network that supports payments from one user to another via a mobile device
Evolution of robo-advisors
Robo 1.0: fill survey & clients manage themselves Robo 2.0: Human investment managers invest & adjust for clients Robo 3.0: Asset allocation and portfolio rebalancing based on automatic algorithms. (sill have human final oversight) Robo 4.0: Investments are fully automated due to machine learning artificial intelligence (AI)
Robo-advisors
Robo-advisors: They provide automated portfolio management advice, strategies and services for investors
Main objective of financial advisory
TRUST and CONFIDENCE of retail investors in the financial services sector and ensure the availability, accessibility and affordability of high quality financial advice
Personal financial management (PFM)
The process of controlling personal income and expenses
Main goal behind segmentation practice
Type of products, channels, services and advice your financial institution presents must be customized to the particular segment being targeted
Risk tolerance
is the amount of risk that an investor is comfortable taking or the degree of uncertainty that an investor is able to handle Often varies with age, income, and financial goals.
Guidelines bank follows to segment their individual customer base #3
marketing segmentation affects value added services (VASs) and pricing flexibility
Three key themes of MiFID II are
•Trade and reference data reporting •Compliance and investor protection •Markets venues, instruments and infrastructure