Network Topology Advantages vs. Disadvantages

Tree Topology Disadvantages

As multiple segments are connected to a central bus, the network depends heavily on the bus. Its failure affects the entire network. ▸ Owing to its size and complexity, maintenance is not easy and costs are high. Also, configuration is difficult in comparison to that in other topologies. ▸ Though it is scalable, the number of nodes that can be added depends on the capacity of the central bus and on the cable type.

Mesh Topology Advantages

The arrangement of the network nodes is such that it is possible to transmit data from one node to many other nodes at the same time. ▸ The failure of a single node does not cause the entire network to fail as there are alternate paths for data transmission. ▸ It can handle heavy traffic, as there are dedicated paths between any two network nodes. ▸ Point-to-point contact between every pair of nodes, makes it easy to identify faults.

Mesh Topology Disadvantages

The arrangement wherein every network node is connected to every other node of the network, many connections serve no major purpose. This leads to redundancy of many network connections. ▸ A lot of cabling is required. Thus, the costs incurred in setup and maintenance are high. ▸ Owing to its complexity, the administration of a mesh network is difficult.

Bus Topology Advantages

easy to set up, handle, and implement. best-suited for small networks and costs less.

Star Topology Advantages

Due to its centralized nature, the topology offers simplicity of operation. ▸ It also achieves isolation of each device in the network. ▸ Adding or removing network nodes is easy, and can be done without affecting the entire network. ▸ Due to the centralized nature, it is easy to detect faults in the network devices. ▸ As the analysis of traffic is easy, the topology poses lesser security risk. ▸ Data packets do not have to pass through many nodes, like in the case of a ring network. Thus, with the use of a high-capacity central hub, traffic load can be handled at fairly decent speeds.

Star Topology Disadvantages

Network operation depends on the functioning of the central hub. Hence, central hub failure leads to failure of the entire network. ▸ Also, the number of nodes that can be added, depends on the capacity of the central hub. ▸ The setup cost is quite high.

Bus Topology Disadvantages

The cable length is limited. This limits the number of network nodes that can be connected. This network topology can perform well only for a limited number of nodes. When the number of devices connected to the bus increases, the efficiency decreases. It is suitable for networks with low traffic. High traffic increases load on the bus, and the network efficiency drops. It is heavily dependent on the central bus. A fault in the bus leads to network failure. It is not easy to isolate faults in the network nodes. Each device on the network "sees" all the data being transmitted, thus posing a security risk.

Ring Topology Advantages

The data being transmitted between two nodes passes through all the intermediate nodes. A central server is not required for the management of this topology.▸ The traffic is unidirectional and the data transmission is high-speed.▸ In comparison to a bus, a ring is better at handling load.▸ The adding or removing of network nodes is easy, as the process requires changing only two connections.▸ The configuration makes it easy to identify faults in network nodes.▸ In this topology, each node has the opportunity to transmit data. Thus, it is a very organized network topology.▸ It is less costly than a star topology

Ring Topology Disadvantages

The failure of a single node in the network can cause the entire network to fail. The movement or changes made to network nodes affect the entire network's performance. ▸ Data sent from one node to another has to pass through all the intermediate nodes. This makes the transmission slower in comparison to that in a star topology. The transmission speed drops with an increase in the number of nodes. ▸ There is heavy dependency on the wire connecting the network nodes in the ring.

Tree Topology Advantages

The tree topology is useful in cases where a star or bus cannot be implemented individually. It is most-suited in networking multiple departments of a university or corporation, where each unit (star segment) functions separately, and is also connected with the main node (root node). ▸ The advantages of centralization that are achieved in a star topology are inherited by the individual star segments in a tree network. ▸ Each star segment gets a dedicated link from the central bus. Thus, failing of one segment does not affect the rest of the network. ▸ Fault identification is easy. ▸ The network can be expanded by the addition of secondary nodes. Thus, scalability is achieved.