Debate Unit 1 Test
Net benefits
A DA plan causes that CP does not
Permutation
A argument saying CP is not competitive to CP
Alt. Cause
A case arg for a different reason why the problem would be caused
Impact
A negative effect/result
Counterplan Text
A plan text that explains what the Counterplan does
Brink (U)
A sudden and drastic change will occur
Plan Text
A text setting the terms of the plan
What is a warrant?
An Assumption based on claim and data
Impact Turn
Claim that impact wont happen
What makes up a toulmin model?
Claim —> Data —> Warrant
Internal Link
Connection between link and impact
Offense
DA to CP
Defensive Response
Denying
Econ DA (IL)
Economic Decline Is War
Econ DA (U)
Economy Stable now
Aff Stock(Solvency)
Effectiveness of plan
Constructive Speech
First 4 Speeches that introduce proposals and arguments
Nuc DA link
GND will crown out nuclear power
Counterplan Solvency
How CP solves
What is a timeframe
How long it will take for impact to occur
Link
How plan leads to negative reaction
Aff Stock( Topicality)
If plan follows resolution
Affirmative Stock (Significance)
Importance of the harms
What is an Affirmative
Introduce a plan to solve the harms in the SQUO
Econ DA link
JG would cannabalize private sector
Aff Stock (Inherency)
Keeps harm from being done
Rebuttal
Last 4 Speeches where they refute and resolve the debate
Nuclear DA( ! )
Nuc prolif causes inst. and risks Nuc. Conflict.
Nuclear DA(IL)
Nuc. exports key to Nuc. Prolif.
N(L)
Plan does not cause DA
Solvency Deficits
Plan solves something that CP does not
Aff Stock (harms)
Problems in SQUO
Link Turn
Proving that link helps plan
Cross Examination
Questioning period of 3 minutes upon a constructives data and plan.
Theory
Reason why CP bad for debate
Uniqueness
SQUO
SHITS
Significance, Harms, Inherency, Topicality, Solvency
Linear (U)
Slowly Descending into worse situation
What is a claim
Statement
What is data?
Statistics and Examples
Who invented the Toulmin Model?
Steven Toulmin
Offensive Response
Switching their sides
No Solvency
The plan doesn't solve
Status Quo (Squo)
The situation now
What makes up Impact Calc
Timeframe, Probablity, Magnitude
What is the Negative
To say the AFF plan is not good
Nuclear DA responses
US already losing Nuclear power lead Economist 23, GND don't require a phaseout of Nuc. Power Meinitz 20, states don't want nukes and can't exploit them mueller 21
Nuc DA (U)
US has lead in Nuc. Export
GND plantext
USFG should substantially increase Fiscal Redistribution in the US by adopting a GND FJG
Econ DA responses
Walt 20, Adinolfi 23 inflation inevtiable bc of corporate greed, A JG will act as a buffer from recession because jobs are guaranteed
Econ DA ( ! )
War
What is magnitude
What is the scale of the impact and area of effect
Competition
Whether there is a forced choice between CP and plan
N(IL)
Why Link does not connect to impact
N(U)
Why SQUO BAD
N(!)
Why plan does not cause impact
Mutual Exclusivity
You can only do CP or Plan at same time
Why am i gay
You like men
What is the Toulmin Model?
a tool for structuring arguments
What is probability
how likely is it for the impact to occur
